Comments on: Exit Interviews: Leave With a Smile https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/ A work fashion blog offering fashion, lifestyle, and career advice for overachieving chicks Sun, 12 Nov 2023 02:50:03 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.5 By: mrc https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/#comment-1958484 Wed, 30 Oct 2013 20:13:41 +0000 https://corporette.com/?p=20165#comment-1958484 I couldn’t disagree more! I work for a company that has fired poor managers because they were causing so many good employees to quit. It’s important to provide honest information.

If the person in question isn’t a manager, you might just want to give HR a heads up, like “I’ve experienced some issues with Samantha missing deadlines. It’s probably worth mentioning to her manager in case she has questions about missed orders.” A casual mention will put it on the record without making you look like a big whiny butt.

]]>
By: anonymous https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/#comment-623319 Tue, 03 Jan 2012 23:30:19 +0000 https://corporette.com/?p=20165#comment-623319 In reply to Joy.

Exactly.

Not the same thing as an exit interview, but here are some examples from my own experience.

–I turned down a job in another field because someone was openly telling racist jokes in a public space. Some of the managers were racist, too, one mistook me for a woman who had worked there for years who looked nothing like me, but the person telling the joke was a consultant. I only mentioned him when I explained why I was not accepting the position. I learned years later that the guy got fired.

Another employee at the company, with whom I worked a few years later at a different company in a completely different part of the country, actually had the nerve to complain to me about how I had been responsible for the man losing his assignment.

I was dumbfounded. I said, “Did you expect me to ignore a man loudly telling a racist joke in the middle of [a public area]?” The guy continued to think I was a cruel, hypersensitive bitch.

–As a summer associate, another summer associate asked me to speak to the head of the summer associate program because of something very disturbing that had happened. We spoke to other summer associates and they all nodded about how unfortunate it was, but not a single one offered to come with us. It was very uncomfortable, but something was done. Neither one of us went back to work at the firm, although fortunately, we both got offers.

Obviously, it was easier to complain in both of these scenarios than at the end of a permanent employment relationship, but it still was not easy.

I hate free riders. On the occasions that they come crying about some injustice that’s finally happened to them I have no sympathy.

]]>
By: anonymous https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/#comment-623299 Tue, 03 Jan 2012 23:14:24 +0000 https://corporette.com/?p=20165#comment-623299 In reply to Amelia.

I agree. It shocks and depresses me that so many women here think that doing nothing is the answer. If a structure supports an unreasonable person who also is racist or sexist, a subordinate is unlikely to be able to “handle the situation” except by leaving.

]]>
By: Carla Harper https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/#comment-606545 Thu, 22 Dec 2011 16:45:48 +0000 https://corporette.com/?p=20165#comment-606545 In reply to Anon.

That excuse of “it’s the alcohol talking” doesn’t hold water. Criminals use it all the time, and if a court of law won’t accept it, you shouldn’t either. I am sorry, but saying “I was drunk” is a lie. You are the same person if you are drunk, but with less ability to choose your words carefully, or to filter your comments. If what was said was just said rudely that’s one thing. But what he said was probably the truth, it is just hard to admit that.

]]>
By: Shosh https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/#comment-605556 Thu, 22 Dec 2011 01:01:12 +0000 https://corporette.com/?p=20165#comment-605556 HR is not your friend.
HR works for management, including your boss, yes, including the boss you want to complain about.
You can pretend that HR is even-handed but they never will be.
If you want, on your way out, complain. You are leaving anyway. But it won’t make any difference.
If you really want to make a difference, maybe threaten a lawsuit unless you receive severence pay for harassment or discrimination or hostile work environment or whatever. Money talks. And HR is afraid of lawsuits. But they are not afraid of your simply “bad review” of your boss.

]]>
By: Joy https://corporette.com/exit-interviews-leave-with-a-smile/#comment-605248 Wed, 21 Dec 2011 21:03:50 +0000 https://corporette.com/?p=20165#comment-605248 The reality is that it’s hard to provide consequences for a bullying partner if no one stands up and says something. Without formal complaints, it is next to impossible to do something about a bad manager, even a bullying one. I’ve personally seen consequences when people have had the courage to complain through exit interviews and 360 degree interviews, but too often people don’t do that. I understand the fear, but at the same time you have to know that nothing will happen as a result.

]]>